update matrix moderation guidelines based on infra-team discussion #181
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
bug
duplicate
enhancement
help wanted
host: grafana
host: netbox
invalid
question
renovate
waiting on upstream
wontfix
No milestone
No assignees
5 participants
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set
Reference
CCCHH/ansible-infra!181
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "lilly/moderation-guidelines"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
You can view your changes at https://staging.infra-docs.hamburg.ccc.de/pr181/
aaf8c7d06400586e21cd00586e21cd46a1bbc8da46a1bbc8da5c639ebc315c639ebc3151f66e995851f66e9958ecafe6a4e7ecafe6a4e7e60a27be20e60a27be20ece5df20b8WIP: update matrix moderation guidelines based on infra-team discussionto update matrix moderation guidelines based on infra-team discussionHave to break for dinner, I'll continue later
@ -7,2 +9,3 @@All Matrix rooms created around CCCHH and which are considered *official* are subject to centralized moderation.This moderation is enforced by a [Draupnir](https://github.com/the-draupnir-project/Draupnir) bot on a techincal level and operated by a dedicated sub-team of the Infra Group.This moderation is enforced by a [Draupnir](https://github.com/the-draupnir-project/Draupnir) bot on a techincal level and operated by a dedicated team of CCCHH people on an organisational one.The end of the sentence appears to be mangled?
@ -7,2 +10,3 @@All Matrix rooms created around CCCHH and which are considered *official* are subject to centralized moderation.This moderation is enforced by a [Draupnir](https://github.com/the-draupnir-project/Draupnir) bot on a techincal level and operated by a dedicated sub-team of the Infra Group.This moderation is enforced by a [Draupnir](https://github.com/the-draupnir-project/Draupnir) bot on a techincal level and operated by a dedicated team of CCCHH people on an organisational one.The team is mixed but represents at least our [Vorstand](https://wiki.hamburg.ccc.de/verein:vorstand:start), [Vertrauenspersonen](https://wiki.hamburg.ccc.de/verein:offizielles:vertrauenspersonen) and the [Infra-Team](https://wiki.hamburg.ccc.de/intern:infra-team).The team consists of representatives of at least our...
@ -18,3 +22,3 @@- Prohibited content includes spam, pornography, harassment, and fascist-like behavior. We remove such content and subsequently ban the user responsible (see [Matrix: Taking Moderation Action](../guides/matrix-taking-moderation-action.md)).- The CCCHH admin account may be used under special circumstances to issue warnings and explain the moderation team’s decisions in general terms. It does not respond to DMs and does not engage in discussions. If moderation action is to be discussed, people are referred to the moderation team at [matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de](mailto:matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de) instead.- The moderation team discusses and chooses an approprite moderation action for questionable behavior together. While crass breach of our rules can result in swift action (e.g. porn bots) social dynamics are discussed internally and a decision which the whole team can defend should be reached.@ -20,1 +24,3 @@- The CCCHH admin account may be used under special circumstances to issue warnings and explain the moderation team’s decisions in general terms. It does not respond to DMs and does not engage in discussions. If moderation action is to be discussed, people are referred to the moderation team at [matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de](mailto:matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de) instead.- The moderation team discusses and chooses an approprite moderation action for questionable behavior together. While crass breach of our rules can result in swift action (e.g. porn bots) social dynamics are discussed internally and a decision which the whole team can defend should be reached.- The moderation team has at their disposal a few technical and social tools and options. Importantly the chosen tool must be suitable to enforce our rules (i.e. not be ineffective), necessary to accomplish so (i.e. a more mild choice would not work), and appropriate (i.e. the downsides for anyone invovled do not stand in stark contrast with rule enforcement). Notably, disregard for the moderation teams decision (e.g. ban evasion or not accepting a written warning) can lead to harder measures.I wouldn't say we accomplish our rules but rather that the aforementioned enforcement is accomplished. Otherwise thanks for the pointers.
ece5df20b85f19629480New commits pushed, approval review dismissed automatically according to repository settings
Seems reasonable with no obvious complaints, but am also rather tired right now.
Otherwise fine. Thank you!
@ -20,1 +24,3 @@- The CCCHH admin account may be used under special circumstances to issue warnings and explain the moderation team’s decisions in general terms. It does not respond to DMs and does not engage in discussions. If moderation action is to be discussed, people are referred to the moderation team at [matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de](mailto:matrix-moderation@hamburg.ccc.de) instead.- The moderation team discusses and chooses an appropriate moderation action for questionable behavior together. While egregious breaches of our rules can result in swift action (e.g. porn bots), social dynamics are discussed internally, and a decision which the whole team can defend should be reached.- The moderation team has at their disposal a few technical and social tools and options. Importantly the chosen tool must be suitable to enforce our rules (i.e. be effective), necessary to accomplish so (i.e. a more mild choice would not work), and appropriate (i.e. the downsides for anyone invovled do not stand in stark contrast with rule enforcement). Notably, disregard for the moderation teams decision (e.g. ban evasion or not accepting a written warning) can lead to harder measures.5f1962948004bb14c6f4New commits pushed, approval review dismissed automatically according to repository settings